Comparing job offers in London involves more than choosing the largest salary. This guide gives you a repeatable way to compare take-home pay, commuting costs, working time, benefits, contract terms, progression, and personal priorities before you accept, negotiate, or decline an offer.
Overview
A job offer can look attractive on paper and feel very different once travel, unpaid time, office attendance, probation terms, or irregular shifts are included. A useful comparison therefore measures the whole employment package rather than comparing headline salaries alone.
Start by collecting the written details for each role. If something has only been discussed verbally, ask the employer to confirm it by email or include it in the contract. Create one column for each offer and compare the same categories in the same order:
- Annual salary or hourly rate, and whether pay is fixed, variable, commission-based, or dependent on shifts.
- Estimated take-home pay after the deductions that apply to you.
- Commuting cost, journey time, reliability, and the number of required office days.
- Working hours, overtime expectations, weekend or evening work, and flexibility.
- Holiday allowance, pension arrangements, sick-pay terms, and other benefits.
- Contract type, probation, notice period, start date, and any conditions attached to the offer.
- Training, progression, workload, management support, and how well the role fits your longer-term plans.
This approach works for graduate jobs, entry-level roles, internships that lead to permanent work, part-time jobs, temporary contracts, and remote or hybrid jobs in London. It is also useful when comparing a counteroffer with a new opportunity.
How to estimate the real value of each offer
1. Compare pay on the same basis
For salaried roles, record the annual gross salary and any guaranteed payment separately from bonuses, commission, overtime, or discretionary benefits. Do not treat a target bonus as guaranteed income unless the written offer clearly says when and how it is paid.
For hourly, temporary, or shift-based work, estimate annual income using a consistent formula:
Estimated annual gross pay = hourly rate × paid hours per week × working weeks per year
Adjust the calculation if shifts vary, unpaid breaks are deducted, or the contract does not guarantee a set number of hours. For part-time work, also compare the effective hourly rate after considering unpaid preparation, closing duties, mandatory training, or time spent travelling between sites.
2. Estimate take-home pay carefully
Gross salary is not the amount that reaches your bank account. Your estimate may be affected by income tax, National Insurance, pension contributions, student loan deductions, salary sacrifice, and other deductions. Use a current UK take-home pay calculator as an estimate, then check the assumptions against your circumstances. The result is not a substitute for your payslip or payroll information.
Compare both offers using the same pay frequency and assumptions. If one role includes a pension contribution or salary-sacrifice benefit, record the deduction and the value separately rather than treating it as free cash.
3. Put a cost on the commute
Calculate the expected monthly travel cost from your actual home area to the normal workplace. Check whether the journey involves more than one service, peak and off-peak travel, occasional taxis, or travel between work locations. Use current operator or transport information because fares, routes, and employer policies can change.
Time matters as well as money. Multiply the total daily return journey by the number of required office days. Then estimate the monthly hours spent travelling. A role with a higher salary may provide less practical value if it adds several hours of travel every week and limits your ability to study, care for family, or take additional work.
A simple comparison is:
Adjusted monthly value = estimated monthly take-home pay − monthly work-related travel costs
You can take the calculation further by recording commute time as a separate cost. Avoid assigning a false precision to your time; instead, label the impact as low, medium, or high and explain why.
Inputs and assumptions for your comparison
Use a spreadsheet or table with one row per factor and one column per offer. A practical template looks like this:
| Factor | Offer A | Offer B | Questions to check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gross pay | Annual or hourly figure | Annual or hourly figure | What is guaranteed? When is pay reviewed? |
| Estimated take-home | Your estimate | Your estimate | Are the tax, pension, and loan assumptions identical? |
| Travel cost | Monthly estimate | Monthly estimate | How many office or site days are compulsory? |
| Commute time | Daily and monthly hours | Daily and monthly hours | Is the journey reliable at the required start time? |
| Working pattern | Hours and location | Hours and location | Are evenings, weekends, overtime, or on-call work expected? |
| Holiday and benefits | Written terms | Written terms | Are benefits contractual, optional, or subject to eligibility? |
| Contract terms | Type, probation, notice | Type, probation, notice | What happens if either side ends the employment? |
| Progression | Evidence and timeline | Evidence and timeline | Is training or promotion described clearly? |
Check the employment contract for the exact holiday wording, pension arrangements, probation period, notice period, place of work, working hours, and termination terms. Statutory rights and minimum entitlements can depend on your status and circumstances, so verify current guidance through an appropriate official source or qualified adviser rather than relying on a general checklist.
Benefits should be valued according to how likely you are to use them. A season-ticket loan, private healthcare option, cycle scheme, staff discount, meals, or learning budget may be useful, but only if the eligibility rules and practical value suit you. Mark benefits as guaranteed, conditional, taxable, optional, or discretionary where relevant.
Worked examples
Imagine you are comparing two full-time London jobs. Offer A has the lower salary but requires two office days each week and has a short journey. Offer B pays more but requires five office days and a longer commute. Begin with the written gross salaries, then estimate monthly take-home pay using the same assumptions.
Next, calculate travel costs. If Offer A requires roughly eight office journeys a month and Offer B requires roughly twenty, record those figures separately. Add the estimated monthly travel costs to your table, then compare the monthly commuting hours. Do not describe Offer B as simply “better paid” until you have seen how much of the difference remains after travel.
Now test the result against your priorities. Offer B might still be the better choice if it provides structured training, a clearer route to progression, valuable experience, or a working pattern that suits your responsibilities. Offer A may be stronger if flexibility, study time, lower expenses, or a sustainable routine matters more.
For a part-time or temporary role, make a second calculation using guaranteed hours only. Then create an alternative scenario using likely, but non-guaranteed, additional shifts. Base essential budgeting on the guaranteed figure and treat extra shifts as uncertain income. This prevents an optimistic schedule from making an insecure offer appear more valuable than it is.
Finally, write a short decision summary: “Offer A gives me lower estimated cash income but saves approximately [time] and [travel cost], while Offer B offers [specific advantage]. I would choose B only if [condition] is confirmed.” This makes gaps in the offer easier to identify and gives you a clear basis for negotiation.
When to recalculate and what to confirm
Revisit your comparison whenever an input changes. Recalculate if the employer changes the salary, office attendance requirement, start date, shift pattern, contract length, or benefits. Update travel assumptions when fares, routes, or your home address change. Review the calculation before accepting a counteroffer, moving closer to work, or switching from full-time to part-time hours.
Before making a final decision, ask the employer to confirm any unresolved point in writing. Useful questions include:
- How many days must I work at the stated location, and can that arrangement change?
- Are the advertised hours guaranteed, and are breaks paid or unpaid?
- Is the bonus contractual, and what conditions apply?
- When does the probation period end, and what notice applies during and after it?
- Which benefits begin immediately, and which depend on eligibility or service?
- What training, review process, and progression route are available?
Keep a dated copy of your comparison and the written offer. Recheck official employment guidance and current travel information when rules, rates, or fares change. The best offer is not automatically the one with the highest headline salary; it is the one whose confirmed terms provide a workable balance of income, time, security, development, and personal fit.